Is Making Your Own Cleaning Products Worth the Effort? Let's Crunch the Numbers
- The Cheap Mom
- Mar 27
- 3 min read
Ah, the thrill of DIY. Who doesn’t love the satisfaction of whipping up a batch of homemade cleaning products while feeling a bit like a magic creator in their kitchen? But let’s be real for a second: is it really worth the time and energy to mix up some vinegar and baking soda? Today, we’ll explore the entertaining and sometimes frustrating world of DIY cleaning products. We’ll compare the effort against the cost of those store-bought options everyone raves about. Spoiler alert: you might just chuckle your way to a cleaner home.

Why Bother with DIY Cleaning Products?
What drives us to make our own cleaning products? For many, it’s the appeal of being eco-friendly. Others might want to beat the big brands by using simple kitchen items. Or maybe you’ve just discovered a forgotten stash of baking soda from 2010 while cleaning out your cupboard.
So, what can we really make? The classics include all-purpose cleaner, glass cleaner, and even laundry detergent. We found that making their own detergent reduced their annual spending by 40%. Instead of spending $300 a year on store-bought options, we spent only $180. That’s a solid saving!
Let’s Get Crafty: Basic Recipes
Here are a couple of recipes you can easily whip up from common household items.
All-Purpose Cleaner
Ingredients:
1 cup of vinegar (not the vinegar you used to rinse out last night's dinner)
1 cup of water
10 drops of essential oil (because who wants their home to smell like a salad?)
Instructions:
Mix the vinegar and water in a spray bottle.
Add the essential oil.
Shake it up like you’re at a concert.
Cost Comparison:
Store-bought all-purpose cleaners cost between $3 and $7 per bottle. You just made this for about $1. That’s a savings range of 66% to 85%. Remember, your time is valuable too, but that’s a significant start.
Glass Cleaner
Ingredients:
2 cups of water
¼ cup of vinegar (see? It’s quite useful)
½ teaspoon of dish soap (stick to regular strength)
Instructions:
Mix water, vinegar, and dish soap in a spray bottle (and identify the bottle, please).
Give it a good shake.
Spray it on glass surfaces and wipe away for a streak-free finish.
Cost Comparison:
A decent glass cleaner typically costs around $4. Your homemade version will set you back only about $1.50, leading to a savings potential of 62.5%.
How Much Time Does This Take?
In our fast-paced world, time matters. How long does it really take to make homemade cleaning products? The truth is, it typically takes 5 to 15 minutes, which is shorter than the time it takes to head to the store (and you save a bit on gas). However, that doesn’t account for the time spent watching DIY videos or accidentally getting lost in cat videos.
Pro Tip: Inventory Your Ingredients
Before starting this exciting journey, check your inventory. You don’t want to spend precious time hunting for half-empty bottles of vinegar, only to uncover that jar of pickles from 2015 in the back. Knowing what you already have can save you both time and money.
But Are We Smarter Than Store Brands?
When you lay out the facts, the revelation might surprise you: while you could be saving money, is it worth the potential stress? After making countless DIY cleaning products, the perfect shine on your floors might not justify the chaos. Remember, the big brands have teams of scientists and specialized labs. You’re competing against a few jars and bottles in your home.
Reality Check when Making Your Own Cleaning Products
Let’s not forget the cleanup after your DIY escapades. Not only do you clean the surfaces you just treated, but you may also find yourself needing to mop up spills from your mixing. As you try to achieve a Pinterest-worthy cleaning routine, also consider the mess you may create along the way.
Final Thoughts: To DIY or Not to DIY?
Is making your own cleaning products truly worth the hassle? If you love being frugal and enjoy the satisfaction of beating big brands while crafting your own solutions, then go for it!
However, if you prefer to spend your extra time binge-watching your favorite series rather than contemplating the acidity of vinegar, store-bought products might be a better fit. Sometimes, spending a little more for convenience is perfectly acceptable.
Enjoy the chaos of home maintenance! Cheers!
Comments